Radha Chaudhari in
A quality circle is a small, autonomous group of 3-10 employees who regularly meet to identify, analyze, and solve quality and production problems. As part of Total Quality Management (TQM), quality circles harness the collective knowledge and enthusiasm of employees to improve organizational processes.
The Origins and Objectives of Quality Circles
The concept of quality circles emerged in post-World War II Japan, greatly influenced by quality management pioneers W. Edwards Deming and Kaoru Ishikawa. In the early 1960s, the Union of Japanese Scientists and Engineers ignited the “Quality Control Revolution,” introducing “quality circles.” The first registered quality circle in the USA appeared at Lockheed Missile and Space Company in 1974, saving the company $3 million by 1977. Quality circles soon gained popularity in companies like Hughes Aircraft, Boeing, General Motors, Ford, General Electric, and Bank of America, extending beyond manufacturing to sectors such as healthcare, government, and IT.
The primary goal of implementing TQM and quality circles is to help companies compete in the market by improving service and product quality while reducing costs. Companies without TQM risk being outperformed by more innovative competitors. The main objectives of quality circles include:
- Creating a pleasant workplace
- Improving morale
- Instituting sound human relations
- Establishing control
- Enhancing quality assurance
- Increasing income
Job satisfaction is crucial for quality assurance effectiveness. Quality circles thrive when participation is voluntary and employees are genuinely interested in improving quality. Regular problem-solving and inefficiency addressing within the workplace enhance quality assurance, a key aspect of continuous improvement, or Kaizen. Quality circles, relying on employees’ knowledge about work processes, emphasize constant learning and training.
Quality Circles in Practice
Quality circles are effective in solving various problems, especially in quality assurance (QA). Common QA issues include engineers avoiding unit tests, buggy releases, unreliable test environments, and managerial time pressures. Quality circles, composed of individuals from diverse specializations (developers, system administrators, QA, managers, architects, support engineers), bring a variety of perspectives, enabling a thorough analysis of problems and synthesis of effective solutions.
For instance, a QA team might notice an increase in buggy code. By investigating through a quality circle, it might be revealed that managers imposed unrealistic deadlines on developers, leading to lower quality outputs. Collaborative problem-solving in quality circles can lead to comprehensive solutions, as seen when a developer advocates for better test environment alerts, a manager agrees to reasonable deadlines, and QAs collaborate on improving the test environment.
The Quality Circle Process
Before initiating quality circles, management must understand their importance and support them, either by participating or providing necessary resources. Quality circles should be small (3-10 employees), voluntary, and led initially by experienced problem-solvers. Regular meetings are essential, typically weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly, to maintain motivation. Each session should include:
- Reviewing previous actions
- Identifying new problems
- Brainstorming solutions
- Planning implementation
Creative thinking and clear communication are crucial, as participants from different specializations need to understand each problem thoroughly. Management should avoid setting KPIs or OKRs for quality circles, focusing instead on learning, collaboration, and continuous improvement.
Adapting Quality Circles for Remote Teams
In today’s remote work environment, quality circles can still thrive by adapting their methods. Although brainstorming is more effective in person, remote quality circles are feasible. Key adjustments include:
- Optimal Home Office Environment: Ensure employees have good lighting, ventilation, comfortable furniture, and low noise levels. Consider sponsoring coworking spaces for quality circle gatherings.
- Flexible Scheduling: Find suitable meeting times across different time zones, avoiding early mornings or late evenings to ensure full participation.
- Psychological Safety: Build trust and safety to encourage open discussion. Offsite events can help participants meet in person, fostering trust and enhancing remote collaboration.
- Visual Engagement: Ensure participants use cameras during video calls to enhance engagement. However, be mindful of potential video call fatigue and ensure participants are not overloaded with work.
When Quality Circles Might Not Work
Quality circles are not suitable for every company. If your company culture relies on a strict chain of command or heavily focuses on KPIs, quality circles may not be effective. Discuss with managers about dedicating one working day a month to quality circles. If management is not supportive, avoid initiating quality circles. Full management support and adequate resources are crucial for success.
Benefits of Quality Circles
Quality circles can significantly improve products and relationships within an organization. By fostering a collaborative and positive work environment, they enhance productivity, employee satisfaction, and overall quality, leading to sustained business success.
Like what we do? We’d appreciate a review – it takes just 5 minutes.